• jjjalljs@ttrpg.network
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    4 months ago

    Enough of us choose to get the measles vaccine that measles isn’t a significant concern anymore.

    If it’s not a mandate, people will “choose” not to do it, and then people will suffer and die. There are some things, like vaccines, that the cost:benefit is extremely clear.

    I think living life w/o getting vaccinated should be possible, but far from convenient. I think you should pay extra for insurance, have to home-school your kids, and not be able to use airplanes, trains, etc

    Sucks for the kids. Also how are you going to enforce that? An ankle bracelet? How are you going to make whole the people harmed by someone decides their personal freedom is the only freedom that matters?

    unless there’s a private prison that’ll take you that doesn’t require vaccination.

    Sucks for the other prisoners who get measles because the private prison didn’t want to pay for vaccines.

    But a law forcing me to put anything into my body will always be immoral

    I do not accept this axiom.

    And you should not. If I am killed or seriously injured due to not wearing a seatbelt, that should invalidate any kind of public payment,

    I’m not talking about literal financial transactions. When you die because you didn’t wear a helmet, I lose out on the investment in you. All those years of education, gone. Any job training you had? In the trash. Your mother taking off work to grieve? Ripples of suck spreading through society.

    I think you’re overstating the benefits for society. If I don’t wear a helmet and die, how does that realistically hurt society?

    Presumably you live in a society with people who care about you. If the lead front eng at work died, the project is going to be delayed, we’re all going to be unhappy, we have to ramp someone up. The whole company could fail as a result.

    That’s not even counting the non-work connections.

    Things are connected. Someone dying or being seriously injured is a big rock to drop in the pond, and those ripples affect many people. It’s not just money stuff. It’s also social and opportunity costs.

    • sugar_in_your_tea@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 months ago

      If it’s not a mandate, people will “choose” not to do it, and then people will suffer and die.

      Yes, that’s one of the consequences of stupid choices. The point for a society to figure out is how to contain those consequences to those who made a stupid choice.

      Also how are you going to enforce that?

      The same way we did it during the COVID-19 pandemic, send proof of vaccination to your insurance, airlines, etc. I did that when visiting Canada by car, and people did it when taking airplanes for travel. It worked fine. It’s a little more complicated when the number of vaccinations goes up, but if a company like an airline really cares about it, they can set the parameters for how you can prove it. Then its up to customers to decide whether that process is worth doing, or if they’ll just use a competitor.

      But the fact is, many businesses won’t bother unless it’s really important, like if there’s a breakout or something of a specific disease.

      Sucks for the other prisoners who get measles because the private prison didn’t want to pay for vaccines.

      Prisoners should be able to refuse to go to a private prison and the state should accommodate that.

      Ripples of suck spreading through society.

      Sure, and that’s why safety equipment and preventative medicine is so important. But at the end of the day, it’s my life to throw away, and nobody else has any valid claim to my education, abilities, etc. Someone who cares about those around them will take the necessary precautions to preserve their life for the benefit of those around them, but that decision should remain theirs.

      The only time I think it’s valid to step in and override someone’s choice is if that choice was not made with a clear conscience.